Shaw and Another v Stephani [2026] EWHC 2776 (KB)

Two claimants brought a claim arising from a road traffic accident in Wales. One was an Australian national and the other held both British and Australian citizenship. Both were resident, domiciled and employed in Australia. The defendant’s son (who died in the accident) was a US citizen living in Wales, while his administratrix and mother was a resident and domiciled in the United States.
The defendant admitted liability. An application was made by the defendant’s solicitors to the High Court to decide where the claim should be brought.
Andrew Kinnier KC, sitting as a deputy judge, considered the relevant case law. The burden lay on the claimants to establish the appropriateness of the domestic jurisdiction, and the test was twofold. First, the court would look at connecting factors to determine which forum had the most real and substantial connection to the action. These included not only factors affecting convenience or expense, but also others such as the governing law, the place where the parties resided or carried on business, and where the wrongful acts and harm occurred. Second, if the English court concluded that the foreign court was more appropriate by reference to those connecting factors, the English court would nevertheless retain jurisdiction if the claimant could show by cogent evidence that there was a real risk that s/he would not be able to obtain substantial justice in the foreign jurisdiction. Second-stage factors might also be relevant to the first stage of the test.
The place of the accident would normally establish a prima facie basis for the appropriate jurisdiction. As to the governing law, it was generally preferable for a case to be tried in the country whose law applied. That factor carried particular weight if issues of law (as opposed to the facts) were likely to be important, and if there was evidence of relevant differences in the legal principles or rules applicable to such issues in the two jurisdictions.
Although the practical demands of the litigation might weigh heavily, the court’s discretion was neither defined by nor limited to their consideration. On the contrary, the ultimate objective was to identify the forum in which the case could be suitably tried for the interests of all the parties and for the ends of justice.
The availability of legal funding in England and Wales, coupled with its non-availability in the appropriate forum, might exceptionally also be a relevant factor.
However, the availability of a higher award of damages in a foreign jurisdiction was not, in general, a good reason to decide that proceedings should be heard there.
DJ Kinnier considered the arguments. The starting point for considering the appropriate forum for a claim in tort was the place of ‘commission’, which was England and Wales. In relation to the applicable law, the defendant had accepted that English law applied. Although it was generally preferable to try a case in the country whose law applied, in this case, the likely primary disputes at the quantum trial would be ones of fact, not law. With one important exception, there were no significant contentious legal questions. Therefore, the applicability of English law was a positive and significant factor connecting the claim to this jurisdiction but only to the extent that legal points were likely to arise.
The ‘one important exception’ was the discount rate to be applied for calculating future loss. Two points were relevant: first, the weight, if any, it should attract as a ‘juridical’ advantage to the claimants; second, whether and, if so, to what extent evidence might be required on the precise rate to be applied.
The discount rate was more favourable to claimants in England and Wales than in Australia. However, according to the case law, that point should not weigh in favour of deciding proceedings here. In relation to evidence, if the litigation proceeded in Australia, there might be a question whether English or Australian law applied to the assessment of damages. If English law were to apply, the Damages Act 1996 would be engaged, and so an issue might arise as to whether, for the purposes of section A1(2) of that act, a different rate of return was appropriate because the claimants lived in Australia. Therefore, irrespective of jurisdiction, evidence would be required about investment conditions in Australia to allow the court to decide the appropriate rate. That evidence would not be difficult for an English judge to master.
A substantial, if not the greater, part of the claimants’ losses were and continued to be incurred in Australia. That consideration should, however, be balanced against the fact that the claimants suffered significant injuries and their initial losses occurred in the domestic jurisdiction. The role of the defendant’s insurer, Direct Line, in the litigation and its residence in England and Wales carried relatively less weight.
In relation to the practicality of the litigation, the principal evidential issues in a quantum trial were likely to turn on: the factual and medical evidence; the nature and extent of the claimants’ injuries and their sequelae; and the quantification of the main heads of loss. The appropriate discount rate was also likely to be an important battleground.
On the whole, the location and availability of witnesses to give evidence at trial was not an insuperable challenge, and that would marginally incline the court in favour of the domestic jurisdiction.
Other points included the potential to resolve factual and expert issues and the likelihood that treating clinicians would not be required to give oral evidence. In relation to funding, whatever limits might exist on the availability of insurance to cover adverse costs liability, the claimants did not suggest they could not obtain substantial justice in Australia. Qualified one-way costs shifting was a juridical advantage to which English courts would attach little, if any, weight.
Viewed overall, DJ Kinnier was satisfied that England and Wales was the forum with which the action had the most real and substantial connection.
Malcolm Johnson is head of abuse claims at Lime Solicitors, London
























No comments yet